The Best Cozy Mystery Book Series for Every Type of Reader

📚 The Best Cozy Mystery Book Series for Every Type of Reader

There’s nothing quite like discovering a cozy mystery series you can settle into—like a warm blanket and a cup of tea that lasts for multiple books. Whether you're craving culinary crimes, literary sleuthing, or seasonal whodunnits, there's a cozy mystery series for every kind of reader.

Here are some of the best cozy mystery series, grouped by themes and interests, to help you find your next bookish escape. Who knows—you might even find a new fictional hometown.

🧁 For the Foodie: Hannah Swensen Mysteries by Joanne Fluke

Start with: Chocolate Chip Cookie Murder

If you love small-town charm and dessert descriptions that make you hungry, this series is for you. Hannah runs a bakery in Minnesota and somehow still has time to solve local murders—often with her cat, Moishe, and a batch of cookies close by.

Why readers love it: Recipes are included in each book!

📖 For the Book Lover: Bibliophile Mysteries by Kate Carlisle

Start with: Homicide in Hardcover

Bookbinder Brooklyn Wainwright restores rare books in San Francisco and uncovers more than cracked spines—there’s always a mystery hidden in the margins.

Why readers love it: Literary references, smart sleuthing, and a heroine who knows her way around a dusty library.

🍵 For the Tea Drinker: Tea Shop Mysteries by Laura Childs

Start with: Death by Darjeeling

Set in Charleston, SC, this series follows Theodosia Browning, the owner of a tea shop who always seems to stir up more than just chamomile.

Why readers love it: Southern charm, detailed tea rituals, and themed titles for every type of tea.

🐱 For the Animal Lover: Mrs. Murphy Mysteries by Rita Mae Brown

Start with: Wish You Were Here

Co-written with her cat, Sneaky Pie Brown, this long-running series features a postmistress and her talking pets solving mysteries in a small Virginia town.

Why readers love it: The animals help narrate the story, and you’ll fall in love with the furry cast.

🎃 For the Seasonal Reader: Holiday Murder Mysteries by Leslie Meier

Start with: Mistletoe Murder

Follow reporter Lucy Stone through every holiday of the year, solving crimes while navigating small-town traditions and raising her family.

Why readers love it: Festive settings, relatable characters, and a touch of nostalgia with every book.

🧶 For the Hobbyist: Seaside Knitters Mysteries by Sally Goldenbaum

Start with: Death by Cashmere

In a cozy coastal town in Massachusetts, a group of knitters gathers weekly—and often unravels more than yarn. Think friendship, sweaters, and seaside secrets.

Why readers love it: Found-family vibes and atmospheric storytelling.

💌 For the Mail-Loving Mystery Fan: Letters by Lanternlight

Start with: Murder at Sugar & Spice Bakery or The Portrait of Deception

Prefer your mysteries to arrive in the mail? At Letters by Lanternlight, our stories unfold one letter at a time. You’ll explore towns like Huckleberry Hollow and Sand Dollar Sound while solving crimes alongside bakers, bookworms, and a cat detective named Tiger.

Why readers love it: Beautifully printed letters, immersive clues, and a slower, more magical way to experience a mystery.

✨ No Matter Your Mood, There’s a Cozy Mystery for You

Whether you want cats, crafts, or cupcakes with your crime-solving, cozy mysteries offer something for everyone. And with so many series to choose from, you’ll never run out of cozy companions—or clues to follow.

Looking for something a little different? Try experiencing your next cozy mystery by mail!

📮 Start your subscription here and discover a new kind of story.